When I proofread the text of Inherkhau's harpist song (TT 359) sent to me by M. Nico Pollone, I found a few cases where the current repertoire of the Manuel de Codage is problematic, or deserves some remarks. I would like to discuss them here.
You can see a photo of the text on the IFAO web site.
the Manuel provides many variants of the sign R10,
You find R10A,
Each of those sign express ẖrt-nṯr in a slightly different way. Some of them use a hill sign, like a half slope
The question is how those variants are defined and how they should be used. For the signs which have many variants, the risk is that the choice of a particular code could be relatively arbitrary. In this precise case, R10A is probably as good an approximation as we get, and would be a reasonable choice.
the Manuel de Codage lists W59 under varia, and not under a specific kind of vase. In Cauville, fond hiéroglyphique, p. 138, the sign is given the value ḥq.t
, which probably means Dr. Cauville sees it as a variant of W22
In Inherkhau's tomb, the sign is used as a determinative for various kinds of vases. In that respect, it is similar to W23
However, there are two important differences. The neck of the sign in Inherkhau's tomb is much longuer and thinner. Besides, the bottom of the vase is pointy like in
The sign in Inherkhau looks like the milk-jug W20
The importance of vase profiles in ceramology and the absence of an exact match might suggest that it's probably better to use the standard W23 sign than a somehow similar sign which could point to a much later prototype.
However, the original Manuel de Codage lists quite a few variants for W59, most of them with a pointy bottom.
Interestingly, the shape is found in the much later Taharqa stelae at Kawa (Lenzo, Pal. Hiero. 7, p. 167, § 391), with more or less the same generic use.
the sign for sr,
the M40 sign looks like its unicode version US1M40AEXTU
Are those particularities worth encoding, and does the Manual, as it stands, provides good solutions for them?
regarding the uses of
given the data I have found about W59
I find the problems of US22